O Beata Virgo Maria – Review by Cathedral Music Magazine

“Where the disc comes alive is in the modern works, particularly Dunphy's haunting Magnificat and McDowall's more strident settings.”

1st November 2024

O Beata Virgo Maria – Review by Cathedral Music Magazine

“Where the disc comes alive is in the modern works, particularly Dunphy's haunting Magnificat and McDowall's more strident settings.”

1st November 2024

Listen or buy this album:

This is truly a disc of two halves: tracks 1 to 13 are Renaissance polyphony by Marenzio (his motet Iste sanctus pro lege), Guerrero (his parody mass on Marenzio’s motet), and Massaino (the Marian motet cycle O beata Virgo Maria); these are followed by three works by living female composers – Melissa Dunphy (her evening canticles for St Paul’s Burlingame), Kerensa Briggs (her Alma Redemptoris mater), and Cecilia McDowall (her St Pancras Magnificat and Nunc Dimittis).

As the album’s title suggests, a Marian thread runs through the programme (only thinly in places – the text of Iste sanctus pro lege is taken from a Magnificat antiphon at Vespers for the feast of a martyr), and the choice of repertoire – especially the rarely-heard Massaino, with its non-canonical text – presents many different facets to Mary. The performances of the older repertoire are clean and well balanced, if not spectacular; where the disc comes alive is in the modern works, particularly Dunphy’s haunting Magnificat and McDowall’s more strident settings.

Review written by:

Review published in:

Other reviews by this author:

This is truly a disc of two halves: tracks 1 to 13 are Renaissance polyphony by Marenzio (his motet Iste sanctus pro lege), Guerrero (his parody mass on Marenzio’s motet), and Massaino (the Marian motet cycle O beata Virgo Maria); these are followed by three works by living female composers – Melissa Dunphy (her evening canticles for St Paul’s Burlingame), Kerensa Briggs (her Alma Redemptoris mater), and Cecilia McDowall (her St Pancras Magnificat and Nunc Dimittis).

As the album’s title suggests, a Marian thread runs through the programme (only thinly in places – the text of Iste sanctus pro lege is taken from a Magnificat antiphon at Vespers for the feast of a martyr), and the choice of repertoire – especially the rarely-heard Massaino, with its non-canonical text – presents many different facets to Mary. The performances of the older repertoire are clean and well balanced, if not spectacular; where the disc comes alive is in the modern works, particularly Dunphy’s haunting Magnificat and McDowall’s more strident settings.

Review written by:

Review published in:

Other reviews by this author:

Featured artists:

Featured composers: